Tamil internment, a manifestation of Sinhala state racism - paper

[TamilNet, Saturday, 17 October 2009, 16:04 GMT]
"Despite the manifest outrage of international human rights groups like HRW and Amnesty International, relief agencies and several Western states, Sri Lanka defiantly continues to brutalize the [Tamil] detainees [locking them up in barbed wire militarized camps]. Whilst various international actors attempt to goad, cajole and compel Sri Lanka to let the civilians go, few have examined the reasons for their incarceration. As far as the Tamils are concerned, it is obvious: this is the latest manifestation of the Sinhala state racism," the British paper Tamil Guardian said in the latest weekend edition.

Full text of the article follows:

Even as the monsoons loom, and despite widespread international alarm and concern, Sri Lanka continues to keep hundreds of thousands of Tamils penned behind barbed wire in militarised tent camps. Since May, when the Colombo government declared victory over the Liberation Tigers, the entire population of the Vanni has been locked up thus. Despite the manifest outrage of international human rights groups like HRW and Amnesty International, relief agencies and several Western states, Sri Lanka defiantly continues to brutalise the detainees. This month the Sinhala state has reduced water supplies, causing untold suffering amid the heat.

Whilst various international actors attempt to goad, cajole and compel Sri Lanka to let the civilians go, few have examined the reasons for their incarceration. As far as the Tamils are concerned, it is obvious: this is the latest manifestation of the Sinhala state racism. Colombo is not only punishing the Tamils for their past defiance of Sinhala rule, it is, like the sovereigns whose rule preceded the pastoral states that emerged in Europe since the seventeenth century, also seeking to impose its authority by instilling terror.

The state will fail in both. There was never a time when the legitimacy of Sinhala domination would be acceptable to the island’s Tamils. Indeed, as scholarship of Sri Lanka has rigorously laid out, it is the Sinhala state’s manifestly chauvinistic violent efforts – in which international actors, including Western states have been implicated, if not complicit – to institutionalise a racial hierarchy that have led to the compaction of the Eelam Tamil identity. At what point – if ever – did it becoming concerning to international actors that the state military was mono-ethnic? As one American military historian has noted, the policy of an all-Sinhala army has been in place since 1962. At the same time it is worth noting how Britain and other Western states have been involved in ‘Security-Sector-Reform’ and military training for at least two decades.

Secondly, state terror will not permanently cow the Tamils. The destruction of the LTTE’s conventional fighting capability has paused the island’s protracted war. It has almost certainly not ended it. If the Black July pogrom in 1983 could not cow the Tamils, then neither will the mass slaughter of 2009 or the continued brutality against our people. Along with several measured international voices, this newspaper has consistently argued that Sinhala oppression will beget Tamil resistance. Tamil faith in West-led liberal internationalism will foreclose space for militancy. For now.

In the meantime, it is worth recalling that the misery President Mahinda Rajapakse is today inflicting on the Tamils is merely a continuation of the suffering visited on them by a series of Sinhala regimes before his (something those pinning their hopes in ‘regime change’ should bear in mind). As the Sri Lankan scholar Neil De Votta has rigorously laid out, even by the seventies Sri Lanka had regressed into an ethnocracy bent on Tamil subjugation. When the Norwegian-led international peace intervention began in 2001, over eight hundred thousand Tamils had been internally displaced whilst hundreds of thousands more had fled abroad.

The present focus on the Vavuniya camps and Sri Lankan state inaction, whilst entirely justified given the acute suffering and the imminent catastrophe of flooding, has meanwhile obscured the country’s complete disintegration into an acutely polarised ethnic blocs. This is not a problem in Sinhala terms, provided minority anger does not turn into challenges to the natural and rightful hierarchy between them and the majority. In short, the reason all ongoing international efforts to get Sri Lanka to treat the island’s inhabitants as equals have failed is because the majoritarian logic embedded in the state – and exemplified by the military – simply does not hold all peoples as equal.

This week, Britain, whilst setting out a catalogue of problems that are clearly linked to the Sri Lankan state’s active policies, announced it will continue “engagement” with the ethnocracy. Almost certainly, this policy of appeasement, which has been tried and failed repeatedly before, will fail again. Whilst the rhetoric of liberalism – exemplified most recently in Colombo’s soliciting of international funding for ‘rehabilitation of ex-combatants’ – will continue to be deployed, in short order it will be clear that none of the ‘post-war’ transformations expected of Sri Lanka will be undertaken. As two eminent scholars, Deborah Winslow and Michael Woost argued, even by 2004, Sri Lanka was not a place where war was taking place, rather the country was war itself: “not a stop-gap, but a new social formation.” Merely tinkering with it – “engagement” – will change absolutely nothing.


Related Articles:
16.10.09   US should help launch international investigations into Sri ..
10.10.09   Release 250,000 Tamils from illegal detention immediately, H..
23.09.09   HRW: World leaders should demand end to Sri Lanka detention ..
10.08.09   Amnesty wants Sri Lanka camps unlocked, war crimes probes
29.07.09   Free civilians from detention camps, HRW tells Sri Lanka
23.07.09   Sri Lanka’s policies contradict IMF loan’s goals - HRW
11.07.09   Amnesty calls for war crimes probe after doctors paraded
02.07.09   Rights Coalition urges Obama to initiate War Crime investiga..


External Links:
AIUSA: Beaches, Palm Trees, Displacement – Welcome to Sri Lanka’s War Zone
HRW: Sri Lanka: Avoid a Postwar Witch Hunt
Amnesty: Sri Lanka: Rape in Custody
HRW: Sri Lanka: Free Civilians From Detention Camps
AI: Statements by detained doctors underline need for independent inquiry
Amnesty: AI Calls on Obama Administration, U.N. Security Council to Act Now to Save Sri Lankan Civilians
HRW: Sri Lanka: Satellite Images, Witnesses Show Shelling Continues
HRW: Sri Lanka: Tensions Mount as Camp Conditions Deteriorate
HRW: Sri Lanka: Adopt International Inquiry for Aid Worker Killings
Amnesty: Satellite Imagery Offers Glimpse on Sri Lankan War Zone
HRW:  World Leaders Should Demand End to Detention Camps
HRW: Sri Lanka: Execution Video Shows Need for International Inquiry
HRW: HRW letter to EU foreign ministers on Sri Lanka IDPs, Sept 2009

 

Latest 15 Reports
 
Find this article at:
http://www.tamilnet.com/art.html?catid=13&artid=30464