Constituent Assembly illegal - Don

[TamilNet, Monday, 19 April 2004, 01:20 GMT]
"There is no legal basis for establishing a constituent assembly. In fact, Article 76(1) of the Constitution states that parliament shall not abdicate or alienate its legislative power, and shall not set up any authority with any legislative power. It is, therefore, expressly prohibited to set up a constituent assembly for the purpose of making law," said Professor emeritus Nihal Jayawickrama in an interview with Sunday Leader, a popular Colombo weekly.

PDF IconSri Lanka's Constitution (5 Mbyte)
"If a government founded on a southern mandate chooses to violate the constitution, what is there to prevent the TNA, which secured a decisive and unequivocal mandate from the north and east, to also violate the constitution and establish its own constituent assembly, based on northern and eastern votes, and adopt its own constitution for that region?" Dr.Jayawickrama questioned.

He added that the "Article 82 of the Constitution provides that it may be amended, or repealed and replaced, by parliament if not less than two-third of its members vote in favour. The amendment of a few provisions (articles 1, 2, 3, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 30(2) and 62(2)) also require approval at a referendum."

He warned that it [convening a constituent assembly] is an intentional violation of the constitution for which the President, if she participates in the exercise, is liable to be impeached under Article 38 of the Constitution.

Explaining that a constituent assembly is a body which is fully representative of the country and its people, Dr.Jayawickrama said that the assembly is convened only when it becomes necessary for a country to make a new beginning, to establish a new legal order.

Agreeing that there are many provisions in our constitution which need to be reviewed and revised, he advocated that time for doing so would be after a final settlement is reached with the LTTE and hostilities end.

Asked if the defence of "necessity" can be used to support a constituent assembly, Dr.Jayawickrama said, " Constitutional experts have described it as a 'transient phenomenon' of dubious origin...A lawfully established government cannot deliberately plan to act in violation of the constitution in the expectation of being able to invoke the defence of 'necessity' to protect it from the consequences of its unlawful conduct."

He also said a referendum following the proceedings in the constituent assembly will make no difference to the illegality of the constituent assembly.

Dr. Jayawickrama was Professor of Law at the Universities of Hong Kong and Saskatchewan, where he taught comparative constitutional law. He was permanent secretary to the Ministry of Justice when the constituent assembly was convened in 1970, and was involved in the processes that led to the drafting and adoption of the 1972 constitution.

 

Latest 15 Reports
03.12.19 23:27  
Challenging 2006 EU ban on LTTE, next step of legal activism on principled grounds: Mendis
02.12.19 23:24  
China, Pakistan send top diplomats to meet Gotabaya in Colombo
01.12.19 23:46  
Gotabaya seems to have bought 5 years from India to wage ‘development’ genocide in North-East
30.11.19 23:51  
India strengthens defence ties with Japan
29.11.19 18:45  
New Delhi appeases Colombo as Eelam Tamil leaders fail to demand international mediation
28.11.19 07:59   Photo
Collective message from Tamils on Heroes Day: Rajapaksas can’t kill Tamil Eelam dream
27.11.19 10:46   Photo
University students, Shivaji brave SL restrictions on veneration of Tamil Eelam Heroes in Jaffna
26.11.19 23:28   Photo
Colombo attempts to officially block students from marking Heroes Day at Jaffna University
25.11.19 23:32   Photo
People mobilise in resolute to mark Tamil Eelam Heroes Day amidst Rajapaksas return
24.11.19 19:59  
Demand Tokyo Co-chairs, India to bring international mediation between Tamils and GoSL
23.11.19 22:58   Photo
US, Indian think-tanks call for deepening of Indo-Pacific ties ahead of 2+2 meetings
22.11.19 23:13  
Russian naval vessel visiting Hambantota coincides with return of Gotabaya Rajapaksa
21.11.19 23:41  
Former IFS diplomat advises New Delhi to embrace Rajapaksas trading off rights with interests
20.11.19 23:04  
US ambassador-turned-consultant hints at capitalising on ‘shared interests’ with Gotabaya
19.11.19 22:50   Photo
Indian FM visits Gotabaya to ensure Colombo’s conformity to US-India geopolitics in Indian Ocean
 
Find this article at:
http://www.tamilnet.com/art.html?catid=13&artid=11775