Fein: U.S.'s immunity determinations flout due process

[TamilNet, Saturday, 08 December 2012, 14:43 GMT]
In the final legal brief filed with the United States Court of Appeals in the case against Sri Lanka's President Mahinda Rajapakse for civil damages on war-crimes charges, appellants, Dr Manoharan et al.'s attorney Bruce Fein asserts that "[n]either the Constitution, nor the Torture Victim Protection Act (“TVPA”), nor customary international law (“CIL”) crowns the Executive with exclusive authority to determine whether a sitting head of state is immune from a TVPA suit founded on the grisly and universally abhorred crimes of torture or extrajudicial killing under color of foreign law," and argues that the Court should reject the U.S. State Department's contention that "when the Executive speaks on immunity, the judiciary is ousted of jurisdiction to interpret the law, [and that the] Adjudication of the case moves from Article III courts to the Article II President."

No United States Supreme Court decision supports such a startling usurpation by the Executive of the customary duty of the judiciary to interpret the law under the Constitution’s separation of powers, the brief said, pointing to Chief Justice John Marshall's forceful statement in Marbury v. Madison: “It is emphatically the province and duty of the judicial department to say what the law is."

Rajapakse attorneys legal response, as happened in the proceedings in the lower court, depended entirely on the Department of Justice's reassertion of the "suggestion of immunity," to save Rajpakse from criminal charges resulting in civil damages.

Bruce Fein, former US Associate Deputy Attorney General
Bruce Fein, former US Associate Deputy Attorney General
Mahinda Rajapakse
Mahinda Rajapakse (Photo: AP)
Dr Manoharan's Reply brief provides supporting arguments for the appellant's position that militates against providing immunity to Rajpakse from the alleged universional crimes. The brief focuses on the following five legal issues:
  1. Neither the Constitution, nor the Torture Victim Protection Act (“TVPA”), nor customary international law (“CIL”) crowns the Executive with exclusive authority to determine whether a sitting head of state is immune from a TVPA suit founded on the grisly and universally abhorred crimes of torture or extrajudicial killing under color of foreign law.
  2. The TVPA Creates a Cause of Action Against Sitting Heads of State for the Universal Crimes of Torture or Extrajudicial Killing Under Color of Foreign Law.
  3. Supreme Court foreign sovereign immunity decisions concerning in rem actions against foreign government vessels have been misinterpreted and misapplied to confer sitting head of state immunity for unspeakable extrajudicial killings in violation of CIL.
  4. CIL Rejects the Executive’s Optional Sitting Head of State Immunity Power for TVPA Suits Resting on the Universal Crimes of Torture or Extrajudicial Killing.
  5. Unconstitutional Takings. The Supreme Court indicated in Dames & Moore v. Regan, 453 U.S. 654 (1981), that an executive order of the President that extinguished pending legal claims in federal court required payment of just compensation under the Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment.
Attorney Adam Butschek and Mark Potkewitz assisted Bruce Fein acting for the Plaintiffs-Appellants. Tamils Against Genocide [TAG], a US-based activist organization which seeks legal redress for Tamil victims of Sri Lanka's civil war, serves as power of attorney for the plaintiffs and is the sponsor of the litigation.

The complaint was filed first in 2011 at the District Court for this case alleged multiple violations of the Torture Victims Protection Act (TVPA) based on Sri Lanka's President Rajapaksa’s command responsibility for the extrajudicial killings of Ragihar Manoharan, the son of Plaintiff Dr. Kasippillai Manoharan, of Premas Anandarajah, a humanitarian aid worker for Action Against Hunger, and husband of Plaintiff Kalaiselvi Lavan, and four members of the Thevarajah family, all relatives of Plaintiff Jeyakumar Aiyathurai.


Chronology:

 

Latest 15 Reports
21.10.19 23:24  
SL Navy silently extends occupation of coastal lands at Kirimichchai in Batticaloa
20.10.19 23:58   Photo
Sinhala supporters of Gotabhaya encroach into pasturelands in Batticaloa
19.10.19 23:31  
Pentagon steps up maritime defence trade with India, UK seeks IOR opportunities
18.10.19 23:43   Photo
Monk backing Gotabhaya wants Tamil owners to stay away from their lands in interior Batticaloa
17.10.19 19:14   Photo
SL Police resorts to violence in grabbing lands of Tamil fishers in Batticaloa North
16.10.19 23:19   Photo
Chennai Connect and Eezham Tamils reminding Tamil Nadu to assert Tamil geopolitics
15.10.19 23:50  
Colombo destroys dairy-farming economy of Eezham Tamils in Batticaloa
14.10.19 23:48   Photo
Tamil parties in North-East stipulate ‘acid test’ terms to SL presidential candidates
13.10.19 22:15   Photo
SL Governor's latest land grab poses danger to archaeological traces of Eezham Tamils
12.10.19 22:23   Photo
Monks step up campaign against Muslims, want to carve out Sinhala colony in Ampaa'rai
11.10.19 22:07   Photo
Vote for Self-Determination, reject major candidates for more effective boycott
10.10.19 23:31   Photo
SL Police intensifies restrictions on Saiva devotees at disputed ‘chaitya’ hilltop in East
09.10.19 20:17  
Indian Coast Guard trespassed into waters off Jaffna, 18 fishers detained since 03 October
08.10.19 18:43  
Divisional Secretary, TNA MPs must act to release Chegnchoalai lands: civil activist
07.10.19 23:12   Photo
Heinous act by HRCSL: former orphans of Chegnchoalai on the brink of losing lands
 
Find this article at:
http://www.tamilnet.com/art.html?catid=13&artid=35833