2ND LEAD (Corrections)

Tamil plaintiffs oppose US Government's stand on Rajapakse immunity

[TamilNet, Friday, 20 January 2012, 01:41 GMT]
Judge Kotelly of District Court of District of Columbia, after considering the Tamil plaintiffs' motion asking the court to allow the plaintiffs to file a response to the United States suggestion of immunity to Sri Lanka's President Rajapakse, issued an order Tuesday granting permission to plaintiffs' attorney Bruce Fein to file the response on or before 3rd February, and to the United States Government to file a reply on a before 13th February. In the process, Judge Kotelly rejected defendant Rajapakse's opposition to plaintiffs request to be permitted to respond to the U.S. Government's suggestion of immunity.

Rajapaskse's attorney Mitchell Berger from Washington lobby firm, Patton Boggs, had earlier asked the Judge to deny any further action by the plaintiffs.

Berger cited US Government's suggestion of immunity, and said the United States had demonstrated that "the Executive Branch has the sole authority to determine the immunity from suit of sitting head of state" and that "[n]o Court has ever subjected a sitting head of state to suit once the Executive Branch has suggested the head of state's immunity."

Judge Kotelly rejected Berger's argument and set dates for the plaintiff to respond and the US Government to reply.

Plaintiffs' attorney Bruce Fein told TamilNet that "while case law cited by the Justice Department showed that Courts should give deference to the US Government's position, our case is interpretation of a statute where no executive deference is due. Congressional not executive intent governs, and the Congress has given the Court the authority to make the final determination on the immunity question based on the facts of the case."

Mr. Fein added that the plaintiffs in this case are dealing with a sitting President who has amassed unprecedented power in a State where all dissent is suppressed, and a head of State who is alleged to have committed war-crimes and crimes against humanity. We hope these facts will influence Judge Kotelly's decision on the immunity question, Fein said.

Spokesperson for Tamils Against Genocide (TAG) which is sponsoring the case said, "while we are cognizant of the legal hurdle ahead of us, we are determined to record our opposition to the US Government's stand in suggesting immunity to someone alleged to have committed Universal crimes."


Chronology:

 

Latest 15 Reports
02.07.20 22:26  
Colombo imposes restrictions on Tamil valour related symbolism in schools of North
01.07.20 13:22  
New secret unit among four SL military and police squads competing to arrest Tamil youth in North
30.06.20 22:10  
Tamils blocked from accessing properties near SL Navy training base in Champoor, Trincomalee
29.06.20 23:29   Photo
Moragoda advising Gotabaya prompts Sinhala parties to scrap Provincial Councils
28.06.20 22:06  
India privileging BRIC/RIC over Quad ‘discordant’, says former US top diplomat
27.06.20 22:11  
Indo-Pacific expert wants US to seek opportunities in ‘Sri Lanka’
26.06.20 21:24  
Russia steps up influence on New Delhi to uphold “multilateralism” against US “rules-based order”
25.06.20 23:53  
Pompeo talks about US reposturing troops, mentions India, Vietnam, Malaysia and Indonesia
24.06.20 23:36   Photo
Devananda circumvents court order, manipulates Jaffna fishers to allow poachers from South
23.06.20 22:03  
Sinhala encroachment of pastureland continues unabated in Batticaloa
22.06.20 18:17  
SLMC Chairman: Time for joint Tamil-Muslim efforts
21.06.20 23:11   Photo
Ex-councillor: Poverty-stricken Tamils at receiving end of SL military brutality in North
20.06.20 23:53   Photo
Tamil man killed, Sinhala Army opens fire at motorbike rider at Mukamaalai in North
19.06.20 23:30  
Dr Amir Ali: SL Archaeology aims to obliterate Tamil traces, shrink territory of Muslims in East
18.06.20 21:02  
Colombo steps up surveillance harassment on organisations operating in East
 
Find this article at:
http://www.tamilnet.com/art.html?catid=13&artid=34805