3RD LEAD (Adds details, links)
Ex-Somali defense minister in war-crimes trial in US
[TamilNet, Tuesday, 02 March 2010, 12:09 GMT]
U.S. Supreme Court will hear "war-crimes charges" against former Somali Defense minister and Prime Minister Mohamed Ali Samantar in a civil case this Wednesday, legal sources in Washington said. Samantar, 74, currently lives in Fairfax, Virginia, after fleeing his native country in 1991 to Rome, and then moving to the U.S. to join his wife and children in 1997. Samantar's five accusers say that Samantar bears command responsibility for a "regime of repeated rape, abduction, summary execution, and years long imprisonment in solitiary confinement" of many of their relatives. Samantar's attorneys argue that their client has immunity under Foreign Sovereign Immunity Act.
The questions presented to the Supreme Court are:
- Whether a foreign state’s immunity from suit under the Foreign Sovereignty Immunities Act (FSIA), 28 U.S.C. § 1604, extends to an individual acting in his official capacity on behalf of a foreign state.
- Whether an individual who is no longer an official of a foreign state at the time suit is filed retains the immunity for acts taken in the individual’s former capacity as an official acting on behalf of a foreign state.
Smantar, former Somali minister
The decision of the Supreme Court has potentially powerful policy implications for the United States and its foreign relations, noted legal sources in Washington said.
"The Court's decision has significant relevance to the Tamil expatriates whose efforts are centered in bringing legal action against Sri Lanka political and military officials alleged to have committed war crimes in Sri Lanka against Tamils. U.S. legal precedents are especially relevant as two of the key alleged perpetrators, current Defense Secretary Gotabhaya Rajapakse, and former Sri Lanka Army commander Sarath Fonseka, are either a US citizen or a Green card holder," a spokesperson from US-based pressure group Tamils Against Genocide (TAG) said.
Washington post, tracing the legal action against Samantar said, "[n]atives of Somalia filed suit against Mohamed Ali Samantar in a Virginia federal district court under the Torture Victim Protection Act ("TVPA") and the Alien Tort Statute ("ATS"). Plaintiffs alleged that Mr. Samantar committed torture and other human rights violations while he commanded Somali government agents under the regime of Mohamed Siad Barre. The district court dismissed the case, holding that Mr. Samantar was immune to suit under the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act ("FSIA").
"On appeal, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit reversed, holding that the FSIA did not render Mr. Samantar immune to suit. The court reasoned that the FSIA does not apply to foreign government officials. The court further reasoned that even if the FSIA does apply to foreign government officials, it does not apply to former foreign government officials."
While Samantar's attorney, Michael Garvin, said that a decision against Samantar may open legal suits against US officials in other countries, plaintiffs' attorney, Patricia Millet, countered that US Congress and Executive branch have expressly determined that it is in the US interest to deny foreign officials who engage in torture and killing a safe haven within the U.S., the paper further reported.Center for Justice and Accountability (CJA), a California-based rights group filed the suit in 2004
with another pro bono co-counsel on behalf of five torture survivors:
- Bashe Abdi Yousuf, a young business man detained, tortured, and kept in solitary confinement for over six years;
- Aziz Mohamed Deria, whose father and brother were abducted by officials and never seen again;
- John Doe I, whose two brothers were summarily executed by soldiers;
- Jane Doe, a university student detained by officials, raped 15 times, and put in solitary confinement for over three years; and
- John Doe II, who was imprisoned for his clan affiliation and was shot by a firing squad, but miraculously survived by hiding under other dead bodies.
No person has ever been held legally responsible for the abuses committed by the military government against the civilian population of Somalia in the 1980s, CJA website noted.
07.02.10 Australian MP calls for independent investigations into Sri ..
05.02.10 Gotabhaya opens door for UN investigations of Sri Lanka war ..
04.02.10 Gotabhaya outbursts against UN, International investigations
26.01.10 Genocide a national policy of Sri Lanka, says Tamil Nadu pro..
13.12.09 Fonseka names assassins of Nadesan, Puleedevan
09.06.09 Boyle, Fein charge Sri Lanka of Genocide in Chennai seminar
30.05.09 Evidence points to Colombo culpability to Tamil massacre - W..
31.03.09 Case filed to block US vote on IMF loan to Sri Lanka
22.03.09 US Group to file court action against US vote on IMF loan
26.02.09 Sri Lanka war crimes under U.S. spotlight
15.02.09 Genocide in Sri Lanka - Boston Globe
06.02.09 Fonseka, Gotabaya Genocide charges filed with US Justice Dep..